PHOTOSDETAILSMAPMAPAGENTSHOWING
View All 40 PhotosView Street View

Single-Family

Year 1886

3281 SQ FT

0.51 ACRES

10 ROOMS

5 BEDS

2/2 BATHS

2 CARS

Plymouth Home for Sale

$539,000

425 Collins St
Plymouth WI 53073

Listed by Pleasant View Realty, LLC

Share Property

This Plymouth treasure was built in 1886 on Collins Street over looking a budding City of Plymouth Wisconsin, now The Cheese Capital of the World! Previous owners help to preserve this gem for many years but the current owners have truly restored many parts of this home. With 5 BRs, 2 full baths & 2 half baths, an open staircase to the upper level, an updated kitchen, modern AC and a second floor laundry. There is a large deck constructed above the attached 2 car garage that overlooks the well maintained yard. The carriage house is what truly sets this home apart from the others, it has all of the charm of the period yet is of modern construction. The lower level has 2 garage and a workshop while the upper is a great finished rec room. Please schedule your private showing soon.

Property Details

Listing Details

Price

$539,000

Year Built

1886

Levels

2 Story

SQ FT

3281

Lot Size

0.51 ACRES

Zoning

Residential

Tax Key

59271804010

TaxYear

2025

Property Taxes

$4,393

Property Type

Single-Family

Property Status

Pending

MLS#

1978675

Inclusions

Refrigerator, Oven/Range, Dishwasher, Window Treatments, Washer, Dryer, 2 Pellet Stoves

Exclusions

Sellers Personal Property

Interior Details

Included Appliances

Oven

Refrigerator

Dishwasher

Washer

Dryer

Interior Features

Pantry

Walk-In Closet(s)

High Speed Internet

Exterior Details

Architectural Style

Victorian/Federal

Construction Materials

Wood

Garage Spaces

2

Parking Features

Paved

Lot Features

Sidewalk

Other Structures

Additional Garage(s)

Deck

Patio

Utilities & Energy

Heating

Natural Gas, Radiant

Cooling

N/A

Water Source

Municipal Water

Natural Gas

Radiant Heat

Municipal Water

Videos & Virtual Tours

Pending
View All 40 Photos
425 Collins Street
1|40
Kitchen looking from the pantry
2|40
Kitchen with many updates
3|40
Coffee bar pantry off of the kitchen
4|40
Dining room with plenty of space for a l
5|40
Living Room with great natural light
6|40
The living room looking toward the dinin
7|40
The Library
8|40
The music room with great natural lighti
9|40
Music room
10|40
Front entry
11|40
View from front entry up the stairs
12|40
Half bath on the main level
13|40
Mudroom just inside of the rear entrance
14|40
Top of the stairway
15|40
2nd floor laundry
16|40
Laundry on the second floor
17|40
Bedroom 1 Primary
18|40
Primary full bath
19|40
Full bath attached to the primary bedroo
20|40
Bedroom 2
21|40
Bedroom 3
22|40
Bedroom 4
23|40
Bedroom 5 on the upper level currently u
24|40
Full bath on the upper level
25|40
Half bath on the upper level
26|40
Basement area
27|40
2 car garage with deck and living space
28|40
2 additional garage stalls in the carria
29|40
Deck above the attached garage
30|40
Front view of the carriage house
31|40
Rec room in the carraige house
32|40
Upper level rec room in the carriage hou
33|40
View of the back of the property
34|40
Back view of the home
35|40
Back yard
36|40
Beautiful side yard
37|40
Overhead View
38|40
View from Collins Street
39|40
Parcel Map
40|40
425 Collins Street
Kitchen looking from the pantry
Kitchen with many updates
Coffee bar pantry off of the kitchen
Dining room with plenty of space for a l
Living Room with great natural light
The living room looking toward the dinin
The Library
The music room with great natural lighti
Music room
Front entry
View from front entry up the stairs
Half bath on the main level
Mudroom just inside of the rear entrance
Top of the stairway
2nd floor laundry
Laundry on the second floor
Bedroom 1 Primary
Primary full bath
Full bath attached to the primary bedroo
Bedroom 2
Bedroom 3
Bedroom 4
Bedroom 5 on the upper level currently u
Full bath on the upper level
Half bath on the upper level
Basement area
2 car garage with deck and living space
2 additional garage stalls in the carria
Deck above the attached garage
Front view of the carriage house
Rec room in the carraige house
Upper level rec room in the carriage hou
View of the back of the property
Back view of the home
Back yard
Beautiful side yard
Overhead View
View from Collins Street
Parcel Map

About Plymouth

Plymouth, Wisconsin, is a unique blend of small-town charm and natural beauty. Situated in close proximity to Sheboygan, this welcoming community offers a peaceful and picturesque environment, making it an ideal residence for families and those seeking a peaceful hometown experience.

Boasting local eateries and convenient access to natural amenities, Plymouth stands as a haven for residents looking to embrace a serene lifestyle. The community's commitment to preserving its small-town character is evident in its warm and inviting atmosphere.

Community Population

8,913

Community Area

5.43 SQ/MILES

Community Suburb of

N/A

Community Lifestyle

Suburban

Nearby Schools

Elementary School

N/A

Middle Or JuniorSchool

Riverview

HighSchool

Plymouth

School District

Plymouth Joint

VIEW COMMUNITY

Get In Touch With

Wisconsin's #1 Boutique Broker ™

Suzanne Powers

Suzanne Powers

FOUNDER | CEO

414.963.0000

EMAIL AGENT AGENT PROFILE

Powers Realty - Shorewood

4214 North Oakland Avenue, Shorewood, WI 53211

Request a Showing for

425 Collins St, Plymouth, WI 53073

$539,000

We would love to show you this beautiful property. Please select your preferred showing date and time below. An agent from Powers Realty will be in touch shortly to confirm your appointment.

CHANGE YOUR APPOINTMENT

REQUEST SHOWINGREQUEST INFO

POWERS LATEST PROPERTIES

VIEW ALL
Wisconsin's #1
Boutique Broker ™
POWERS REALTY GROUP OFFICE LOCATIONS

Powers Realty Group, Inc. - Shorewood

4214 North Oakland Avenue
Shorewood, WI 53211

powersrealty.com

414.963.0000

Powers Realty Group, Inc. - Naples / Marco Island

780 Fifth Avenue South, Suite #200
Naples, FL 34102

powersrealtyfl.com

239.682.7476

414.963.0000

suzanne@powersrealty.com

FaceBook Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
Powers Powers Better Business Bureau America's Best Real Trends Verified

© 2026 Powers Realty Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed.
Privacy Policy | DMCA Notice

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Data Source Copyrights
Copyright ©2026 MetroMLS - All Rights Reserved.
Copyright ©2026 Marco Multi List.
Copyright ©2026 M.L.S. of Naples, Inc.

Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified. Powers Realty Group shall not be held responsible for any discrepancy and will not be liable for any damages of any kind arising from the use of this site

Copyright & Content Use Notice

All content on this website, including text, photographs, graphics, videos, listings, data, and other materials (“Content”), is the exclusive property of Powers Realty Group, Inc. or its licensors and is protected by U.S. and international copyright, trademark, and intellectual property laws. No part of this Content may be copied, reproduced, distributed, published, displayed, transmitted, modified, or otherwise used in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical, digital, or otherwise—without the prior written consent of Powers Realty Group, Inc. Unauthorized use of our Content, including screenshots, images, and proprietary data, is strictly prohibited and may result in legal action

RESO MLS Web API Website Design By Rockstar Design

Rockstar Design is a MODX Professional Partner