4858 SQ FT

Year 1940

11 ROOMS

0.14 ACRES

5 BEDS

5 / 1 BATHS

2 CARS

1898611

Whitefish Bay Home Sold

4866 N Newhall St, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217 - Home Sold

Step into this elegantly renovated Whitefish Bay home, where sophistication meets comfort. The main lvl features a rare primary suite, complete with a luxurious en-suite bath, offering a private sanctuary for relaxation, a beautiful KIT open to family room, an office/den, & a dining room. Upstairs, you'll find 4 spacious bedrooms & 3 beautifully appointed full baths, ensuring ample space for family & guests. The finished basement is a true gem, boasting full bath, an egress window for natural light, & a versatile 6th bedroom-perfect for guests or workout enthusiasts. Every corner of this home exudes charm, from the airy open floor plan to the stylish finishes. Experience the perfect blend of elegance & functionality in this remarkable property. Don't miss your chance to make it your own!

Listed By: Shorewest Realtors, Inc.

Brought Buyer: Closing Time Realty, LLC

Listing Price: $1,895,000

Closing Price: $1,850,000

Sold Date: 2025-01-10

Days On Market: 0 Days

Share Property

Amenities & Features

Listing Details

Price

$1,895,000

Year Built

1940

SQ FT

4858

Lot Size

0.14 ACRES

Tax Key

2010482000

TaxYear

2023

Property Taxes

$7,159

Exclusions

N/A

Property Type

Single-Family

Zoning

Res

Property Status

Closed

MLS#

1898611

Interior Features

Included Appliances

Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Disposal, Dishwasher, Microwave, Other

Oven

Range

Refrigerator

Microwave

Disposal

Dishwasher

Washer

Interior Features

Gas Fireplace, Pantry, Cable TV Available, Wood or Sim Wood Floors, Kitchen Island, Walk-In Closet(s), High Speed Internet

Gas Fireplace

Cable TV Available

Kitchen Island

Pantry

Walk-In Closet(s)

High Speed Internet

Heating

Natural Gas, Forced Air

Cooling

Central Air

Water Source

Municipal Water

Levels

2 Story

Exterior Features

Architectural Style

Colonial

Construction Materials

Fiber Cement

Garage Spaces

2

Parking Features

Parking Space, Alley Entrance, Garage Door Opener

Lot Features

Sidewalk

Exterior Features

Patio

Other Structures

N/A

Waterfront Features

N/A

Patio

Utilities

Natural Gas

Forced Air

Central Air

Municipal Water

Photo

Sold

Listed for $1,895,000

Sold for $1,850,000

4866 N Newhall St, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Listed by Shorewest Realtors, Inc.

Whitefish Bay

About Whitefish Bay

About the Community

Overview

Whitefish Bay is a bustling, tight-knit village of tree-lined streets and beautiful parks. It is a community of lifelong residents, filled with landmark businesses and local staples that lend themselves to the sense of pride that comes with living in Whitefish Bay. The village is home to some of the best schools Wisconsin has to offer, including the state’s number one high school. Whitefish Bay is a Bird City Wisconsin and a Tree City USA.

Whitefish Bay Among Top 10 Cities To Live In US.

Recreation

Whitefish Bay is the gem of the North Shore when it comes to outdoor recreation. Ten beautiful parks with green space, playgrounds, and sports facilities are scattered throughout the village streets. Fancy a bike ride? Nearly every house in Whitefish Bay has a park within easy riding distance. For kids, Whitefish Bay offers sports programs for everything from gymnastics to golf.

Whitefish Bay is also home to a wide variety of businesses and eateries. The Bayshore Town Center is the North Shore’s largest shopping mall - look there for big stores like H&M and Barnes and Noble. Surrounding Bayshore along Silver Spring Drive, smaller local businesses abound.

Check out Fox Bay Movie Theater for dinner and the latest blockbuster! Jack Pandl’s Whitefish Bay Inn is the place for a traditional sit-down dinner - the German-American fare there has been a village staple for over 100 years.

COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS

  • The Whitefish Bay Women's Club
  • The Whitefish Bay Garden Club
  • The Whitefish Bay Runners Club
  • The Whitefish Bay Swim Team
  • The North Shore Newcomers Association
  • Whitefish Bay Civic Foundation
  • Whitefish Bay Players, which is a community theater
  • Whitefish Bay Library
  • Jewish Community Center

WHITEFISH BAY PARKS

  • Armory Park
  • Big Bay Park
  • Buckley Park
  • Cahill Square Park
  • Estabrook Park
  • Klode Park
  • Lydell Community Park
  • Old School House Park
  • Silver Spring Park
  • Water Tower Park

See Whitefish Bay featured on the PBS program Around the Corner with John McGivern.

Why Whitefish Bay?

More than just a place to rest your head at night, the Whitefish Bay community is a remarkable place to live, work, and play. With annual events like the Whitefish Bay 4th of July parade and the Whitefish Bay 5k/Fun Run, there’s hardly a shortage of activities to do on the weekend!

If you’ve liked what you’ve read so far about Whitefish Bay, then contact us today.

What Is My Whitefish Bay Home Worth?

If you're thinking about selling your home in Whitefish Bay , make sure to contact us. We offer a complimentary home evaluation. Our real estate agents are experts in the Whitefish Bay market and we offer home staging as well.

Community Population

14,818

Community Area

2.131 SQ/MILES

Community Suburb of

Milwaukee County

Community Lifestyle

Urban

Nearby Schools

Elementary School

Cumberland

Middle Or JuniorSchool

Whitefish Bay

HighSchool

Whitefish Bay

School District

Whitefish Bay

Powers Realty

WORK WITH US

We are Wisconsin's #1 Boutique Broker, consistently ranked a Top Team by Real Trends. Our team represents properties in Wisconsin's Luxury Markets. We leverage cutting edge technology to maximize exposure for our clients properties.

Find Out What Your Home IS Worth

If you're thinking of selling your home in , get a customized crafted report developed by our expert team of local real estate agents to find out your home's accurate value.

POWERS LATEST PROPERTIES